If You Could Ask Jesus One Question, What Would It Be? The Questions People Asked Him in the Gospels
Share
“If you could meet Jesus and ask one question, what would it be?” sounds like a modern thought experiment. The Gospels are already full of people doing exactly that.
A lawyer asks which commandment is greatest. Another asks what he must do to inherit eternal life. Pilate asks, “What is truth?” The disciples ask who is greatest, why they could not perform a healing, when the temple’s destruction will happen, and who can be saved. Religious opponents ask about taxes, resurrection and authority. John the Baptist’s messengers ask whether Jesus is the one who is to come.
The questions differ because the motives differ. Some seek knowledge. Some seek help. Some test him. Some defend status. Some expose fear.
Jesus often refuses to behave like a modern answer machine. He responds with a counter-question, a parable, a scriptural citation, a command, or a reframing of the problem. “Who is my neighbour?” becomes the Good Samaritan. A question about the greatest commandment becomes love of God and neighbour. A trap about taxation becomes a saying about Caesar and God.
The four canonical Gospels present Jesus with distinctive emphases and arrange sayings and episodes for theological purposes. Responsible reading therefore compares parallel passages rather than assuming every Gospel frames each encounter identically.
The Gospel pattern suggests that the most revealing part of the encounter might not be the answer you expect. It might be the question Jesus asks back.
Primary texts
- Matthew 19:16–22; 22:15–40; 24–25
- Mark 8:27–30; 10:35–45; 12:13–34
- Luke 10:25–37; 18:18–30
- John 18:33–38; 20:24–29